@Spug, Feel your pain.
When HH sends out a diff, It MUST be opened up.
As if it is the Stocker one out the box.
What exactly is failing within the diff?
Can't be the exact same failure every single time. Usually not. Hint....If so, it's probably user error? IDK.
Never drop in a new one right out the package. You will never get a "Good One" to trust. Promise.
They all come from the same Chinese factory, OE stocker as well as the retail replacements from anywhere you buy them including from JennysRC.
I could see justifying a "Break-In" of a new unopened Diff.
But one pack gently run is all I might do at most. Then rebuild it, whether you feel it is fine or not.
With any replacement diff, that it is uninstalled, always open it up first. You have it out already in hand. Top it off at a minimum.
But I highly recommend removing ALL the old oil and installing the recommended Thicker oils we all mostly use. (60kF/500k center/20-30k Rr)
DO this out the gate
always, and you can surely get 15-20 packs out of them before preventative maintenance is in order. Throttling under hard loads, landings and impacts will also destroy any diff sooner than later. ALL factory assembled diffs
are low on oil and the oil is just too thin to begin with. The diff can and will literally melt into a molten chunk of plastic and gears with the remaining oil becoming like Tar. A complete $loss$, BB's and all. The center diff can hit 250F degrees in a heart beat. Been there. Temp gun in hand. Not pretty. A mess. Buy a temp gun. A needed inexpensive tool for the ESC, moto, lipos, as well as center diff.
I recommend the Fireteam Metal Alloy Arrma diffs at the Center. Temps will stay cooler. It comes with 300k. BUT is still low on oil. And 500k at a minimum is best for bashing hard.
Still need to open it up and refill it. Never felt the need for an alloy diff at the Fr and Rr diffs. Plastic stocker ones have been fine for me using 6s lipos.
https://jennysrc.com/collections/fi...-50t-spur-gear-ara7618?variant=39857937809462
Tip:
Use a Mugen Seiki diff Shim kit instead of the stocker ones. Way better and will keep the Satellite and Suns gears aligned better. The Arrma diff gear shims are crap and bend and wear out easily. Use a smear of greae on the Output cup Shafts before inserting the BB and Ouput cups. Let the oil bleed out for a while as you fill them. Or you can end up with an underfilled diff without realizing it. Filling is a slow process if done correctly.
https://www.amazon.com/MUGEN-Differential-Washer-M-Spec-MUGC1206/dp/B000BMPK2U
Do diffs correctly or they wil cost you $$$ needlessly. There is a leaning curve with the diffs. Once you learn it you will understand it better. Arrms diffs are needy otherwise. Always failing. Driver input control is also paramount.
I hope your Main Gear/Input Gear shimming is also correct. Never overlook this! Or its also a fail very quickly as well.
Watch some videos to help get the hang of it. Like stated abve in a post, Buy the allo front diff support and Top plate, Helps with cooling also. Plastic one can and will distort and melt when the diff does. Been there.
Good luck.