- Messages
- 4,706
- Reaction score
- 6,495
- Location
- San Antonio TX
- Arrma RC's
- Felony
- Granite
- Infraction
- Kraton 8S
- Mojave EXB
- Outcast 8s
- Typhon 6s
Compared these two monsters. The results were very interesting.
Watch :
Watch :
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Tough one. For stability and longer jumps K8S, for faster backflips and some standing backflips (if I want), or self ride Outcast 8s.Which one do you like better?
What ESC and motor are you using? Castle told me that 34/39 gearing was way too aggressive after my XLX2 with the 1100kv motor from Castle had issues (my bullets came off the ESC on the battery side) . I since went with 30/47 gearing and it seems to be working fine. Over 50mph on grass. That's more than adequate for bashing. At least for me.I know this is an old thread, but I’m wondering about the motor temp on the k8 35/47setup. I see most people running the 39 spool and they talk about needing fans.
I just built a K8 w/ 32/39 gears and I’m trying to see if I’m going in the right direction for the track racing I’ll do in short grass.
I tried 30/39 gearing and it was insanely fast (like 58MPH on grass). But I felt it was not worth it due to the spikes in voltage mentioned. Maybe for a couple of speed passes and no almost constant running, that gearing would be OK, but I like to have fun and jump almost non stop. And it's only like 5 MPH more compared to the less aggressive gearing (30/47). Also, my batteries get pretty hot with the 30/39 gearing. So yeah, I wouldn't go there again. That's just me though. And I also use proline trenchers 4.3 tires, which you have to gear down for obvious reasons. I advise you to keep an eye on your volatage spikes, your temps and to shut down your motor at 170F maximum (that's what I'm doing). Use some big QS8 connectors too. Just my suggestions. Have fun but take it easy when trying out new gearing and set ups. I've blown motors, escs and I puffed batteries when I didn't take it easyMy apologies I forgot to tell you I’m running an XLX2 w/ 1100 kv motor.
I saw many people say they run between a 29 -39 pinion with the 39spur, so I figure I would try. They also say you would need a fan on the motor, so I wasn’t sure if this was normal. I’m trying not to run a fan, but if I need to I have one.
I suspect that you will get some 500 plus amp spikes with that gearing on grass. With 30/47 gearing I saw up to 300amp spikes if I remember correctly, which is acceptable. At least I think it's acceptable. And the top speed was at least 53-55mph on grass with 30/47 compared to the 58 mph on grass with the 30/39 gearing. I honestly don't see the benefits of the extra few miles. I did see the drawbacks of the crazy amp pulls, puffed batteries and de soldered bullets. That's been my experience.@Armarookie43 I did my first test with the rig today in this Texas heat. I'm running XLX2, 1100kv motor, 32/39 gearing, two motor fans, 2 SMC 6900 mah 135c 4S batteries on Proline Masher X tires. The test was to setup the steering alignment, check for heat issues and on road speed test.
Without the fans running on the motor in ran constant 58mph with motor temp at 130 degrees. Round 2 I turned the fans on and did the same speed test and the truck ran 59mph consistently with the motor staying at 110 degrees.
ALL this was done in 96 degree weather. I haven't pulled the logs, but that will have to be part two of this post.
I can say that this 1/5 scale Kraton 8S is a beast and a entire other animal compared to my Talion XL EXB on 6S. I do agree that the speed this truck is running on road is more than adequate for off road, so now its time to find that sweet spot for me with gearing and motor temp.
Time to the pull the data logs, adjust my servo voltage and record all this data.
View attachment 238892
I unfortunately didn’t see castle suggestion until after I ran the setup today for the first time. I did pull my logs, but they didn’t show over 200 amps.Castle also told me my gearing was too aggressive at 34/47 and advised I gear down to 30/47. Bummer, but when they are giving the warranty, I’ll follow suit.
I agree with what your saying, so I’m going to play it safe and put 30/47 gears in tomorrow before I run it on the grass. I’ll pull the data logs and share it in the thread. I don’t care about a few more mph on the grass.I suspect that you will get some 500 plus amp spikes with that gearing on grass. With 30/47 gearing I saw up to 300amp spikes if I remember correctly, which is acceptable. At least I think it's acceptable. And the top speed was at least 53-55mph on grass with 30/47 compared to the 58 mph on grass with the 30/39 gearing. I honestly don't see the benefits of the extra few miles. I did see the drawbacks of the crazy amp pulls, puffed batteries and de soldered bullets. That's been my experience.
Try it out and then check your logs.
Yeah. I just don't want you to experience my failures. I think that you are making the right decision by going with the less aggressive gearing like I did.And yes, please share your data logs here if you can so that we can compare them.I unfortunately didn’t see castle suggestion until after I ran the setup today for the first time. I did pull my logs, but they didn’t show over 200 amps.
I agree with what your saying, so I’m going to play it safe and put 30/47 gears in tomorrow before I run it on the grass. I’ll pull the data logs and share it in the thread. I don’t care about a few more mph on the grass.
What I do care about is having a solid setup, low motor/esc temps and a lot of fun.
Thanks for the help
Yeah I'd go with the 30t. I mean you could run it with just one screw on the top, but yeah, two screws on the top and one on the bottom is more ideal and stronger since the 2028 motor is so heavyQuestion…. I can home from work and put the 47t spur on, but I can only get one screw in the motor mount. Castles website says they recommend 32/47. How’s that possible if it does fit?
I did notice that I’m running g the 56 series motor mount and not the 49. I ended up ordering a 30t pinion.
I believe that I was able to to achieve that because I used the PPS motor mount insert when I was running 35/47 gearing. It's more flexible than the stock 56 series mount.I order a 30t, but it boggles my mind that castle recommended 32/47. When I tried creating that setup it didn’t fit.
We know that going down is always a good thing….
How did you run. 34/47?
Register and gain access to Discussions, Reviews, Tech Tips, How to Articles, and much more - on the largest Arrma RC community for RC enthusiasts that covers all aspects of the Arrma-RC brand!
Register Today It's free! This box will disappear once registered!